Active Video Game Exercise Training Improves the Clinical Control of Asthma in Children: Randomized Controlled Trial
Respiratory clinical research
Comments
2 open comments
DL
Dr. Lena OrtizChange request · May 20, 2026, 9:18 AM
Please keep the summary clear that this was an 8-week pediatric exercise-training trial, not a medication efficacy study.
Abstract objective
DS
Dr. Sofia MartinezResolved · May 20, 2026, 10:03 AM
When we summarize Table 1, please say both groups improved ACQ-6, while FeNO reduction was reported only in the video-game group.
Table 1 outcomes
MC
Mara ChenResolved · May 20, 2026, 10:18 AM
Source check: PLOS DOI, trial registration NCT01438294, funding statement, and CC BY license are visible in the paper.
Citation and license
DR
Dr. Robert KimChange request · May 20, 2026, 11:07 AM
Tone down the final review note around the conclusion. The limitations note says energy expenditure may be underestimated and game intensity could not be individualized.
Please keep the summary clear that this was an 8-week pediatric exercise-training trial, not a medication efficacy study.
Abstract objectiveWhen we summarize Table 1, please say both groups improved ACQ-6, while FeNO reduction was reported only in the video-game group.
Table 1 outcomesSource check: PLOS DOI, trial registration NCT01438294, funding statement, and CC BY license are visible in the paper.
Citation and licenseTone down the final review note around the conclusion. The limitations note says energy expenditure may be underestimated and game intensity could not be individualized.
Limitations and conclusion